Conformance and tiers

Explanation: conformance and tiers

The toolkit grades a plugin against the Advanced Skill Library Standard. Checks emit error or warn findings keyed to requirement ids (for example U5 is the description-quality rule). evaluate composes those checks into a report; tier-report rolls them into the highest tier a plugin satisfies, capped at the tier it declares in library.json so it cannot over-claim.

A description scoring below 0.7 is a warning, never an error - quality is judgment, so the heuristic guides rather than gates. The tiers (Universal / Convergent / Advanced, or Bronze / Silver / Gold) are cumulative: each includes the last. That is why a Bronze plugin can grow into Silver and Gold without rework - the bar rises, the earlier work still counts.

flowchart LR
  B["Bronze / Universal<br/>portable SKILL.md + library.json<br/>+ AGENTS.md + CI (U-checks)"] --> S["Silver / Convergent<br/>adds multi-agent emission,<br/>subagents, commands, chain contracts<br/>(S-checks)"] --> G["Gold / Advanced<br/>adds hooks, self-hosting CI,<br/>eval/regression, release notes,<br/>deprecation (A/G-checks)"]

Each tier is cumulative: Silver includes every Universal check, Gold includes every Silver check. tier-report reports the highest tier a plugin fully satisfies and lists what blocks the next.

The toolkit is itself built to this Standard and validates itself in CI: it declares tier: advanced and satisfies Gold (G1-G10, on top of Bronze + Silver), so node scripts/tier-report.mjs --json reports tier: advanced with an empty blocked - a self-proving example of the Standard. See STANDARD.md for the normative rules.

Silver checks (added in Phase 3A)

Convergent (Silver) reqIds carry the S prefix. The current set:

reqId	What	Standard	Conditional?
S1	library.json agent-targets present + valid	sec 5.1, sec 2.2	no
S2	library.json prefix present + kebab-dash	sec 8.2	no
S3	library.json components index matches disk	sec 5.1, sec 10.3	no
S4	Chain-contract integrity (phantom; missing-when-chaining)	sec 3.6	yes
S5	Workflow skill-existence	sec 3.4	yes
S6	Per-target native-manifest presence	sec 5.1, sec 10.1	yes
S7	Command-contract (maps-to resolves to one skill/workflow; description present)	sec 3.2	yes
S8	Components index mirrors what is on disk, in both directions (no orphan or phantom entries)	sec 5.1	no

One Universal check was added in the v0.2 hardening: U9 (version-match: package.json version must equal library.json version, the source of truth). A U10 no-dashes check shipped at the same time; it was retired in Standard v0.11 as a stylistic house preference rather than a portability requirement, and now lives only as an opt-in author-time hook. A later Universal check, U13 (skill-registration), was added in Standard v0.12 (ADR 0035): a plugin whose manifest enumerates skills must register every skill it ships on disk (a skill on disk but unregistered ships invisibly to installers). The full Universal set (U1-U9, U11-U13) is documented in ../reference/universal-checks.md.

S6 (per-target native-manifest presence) fires only when agent-targets is declared; it checks that each declared target has its generated native manifest on disk. The repository declares agent-targets: ["claude", "codex"] and emits both manifests. The components index (S3) is now present in library.json, so the Silver burndown is empty; the toolkit has since closed the Gold checks (G1-G10) too and declares tier: advanced.

Visible burndown - reading blocked.convergent as the climb to Silver

tier-report caps satisfies at the plugin’s declared tier (so a Bronze plugin cannot accidentally claim Silver), and lists everything above the ceiling as blocked.<next-tier>. The gate-runner (check.mjs) follows the same model: only errors at-or-below the declared tier fail the gate. So a Bronze plugin that adds Silver requirements gradually sees its blocked.convergent list shrink, while CI stays green throughout the climb. The repository completed the full climb to Gold: the toolkit now declares tier: advanced and blocked is empty (Bronze, Silver, and Gold all satisfied). The Silver checks (S1-S8) and Gold checks (G1-G10) are documented in ../reference/silver-checks.md and ../reference/gold-checks.md, and the Universal floor in ../reference/universal-checks.md.