The family registry

Measured 2026-09-05 · catalogue e421c40 · every member graded at the sha the catalogue pins

This tier reports structural conformance to a written Standard - deterministic and reproducible; it is not a content review, a safety audit, or a statement that the skills work. What a tier does not certify.

This page is the measurement, regenerated on every deploy so its date cannot drift from its numbers. What the columns mean, why the collection reads as it does, what would turn it green, and the record of the episode in which an earlier hand-run version of this page carried a false verdict all live on the family registry reference page, which no generator overwrites.

Collection Evaluation Catalogue v1.75.0 Evaluated 2026-09-05 Exit 1

product-on-purpose

catalogue version 1.75.0  /  Product on Purpose

Marketplace-scope evaluation. Every member is graded at its own declared tier and its own Standard pin; the collection is red if any member fails its own claim, or if the catalogue itself is undeliverable.

Collection verdict
RED
self-consistency worst-member
Coverage
6/6
members graded
Failing own claim
2
pm-skills, thinking-framework-skills
Collection findings
0
0 error, 0 warn
Unresolvable entries
0
broken catalogue entries
RED
collection
Verdict
At least one member fails its own claim, or the catalogue is broken
Graded 6 of 6 member(s).
--

What this run actually graded

Stated in words, not left to the pin columns alone.

Scope of this verdict

This run graded the LOCAL CHECKOUT of each member it could resolve, not the tree at the registry pin. Remote fetch-at-sha is deferred (ADR 0039, question 1). The pin, entry version and graded sha below are shown for every member, including the ones where they agree, so agreement is never inferred from silence.

02

Member ledger

One row per catalogue entry, with the pin columns shown unconditionally.

MemberStatusDeclaresEarnsErrWarnDebtEntry verPinGradedDivergence
pm-skills FAILS OWN CLAIM none declared none 234 40 0 2.33.0 7a42570 7a42570 in sync
thinking-framework-skills FAILS OWN CLAIM Advanced Convergent 1 137 130 0.13.0 9aab9f3 9aab9f3 in sync
writing-style-catalog OK Universal Universal 0 4 1 0.13.0 00e4884 00e4884 in sync
agent-skills-toolkit OK Advanced Advanced 0 0 0 1.17.1 4ba1ae6 4ba1ae6 in sync
critique-skills OK Convergent Convergent 0 7 7 0.1.6 30ec617 30ec617 in sync
product-lifecycle-templates OK Advanced Advanced 0 1 1 0.5.0 aaa1bc2 aaa1bc2 in sync

What the columns mean

Standard debt counts findings held below their severity by that member's own Standard pin, whether the check postdates the pin or a tightening has not reached it yet: green-by-an-old-pin, made visible. Pin is what the catalogue advertises; Graded is the checkout this run actually read. They are shown for every member, including the ones where they agree.

03

Not graded, and why

The difference between a broken artifact and an incomplete workstation.

Every catalogue entry resolved to a member on this machine.

04

Collection findings

Defects that exist only between members; no member's own gate reports these.

No cross-member findings. The catalogue parses, every entry resolves or is honestly reported, no two members collide on a component name, and every entry version agrees with its member's own manifest.

05

Advisory

Deterministic, and structurally unable to move the verdict.

Advisory, and structurally unable to change the verdict

These analyses are deterministic - they are string comparisons, not judgments - but they are not conformance facts, so they are namespaced away from the findings the verdict reads.

  • TRIGGERCross-member trigger-surface overlap: none above threshold
  • SHAPECommand-versus-skill divergence: thinking-framework-skills: think-research-framework; agent-skills-toolkit: askit-build-skill; agent-skills-toolkit: askit-evaluate
  • LINEAGEContent lineage between members: none
06

Report metadata

Provenance for this evaluation.

Catalogueproduct-on-purpose v1.75.0
Root/home/runner/work/_temp/registry/catalogue
Member search roots/home/runner/work/_temp/registry/members
Tier distributionnone: 1, Convergent: 2, Universal: 1, Advanced: 2
Aggregation ruleself-consistency worst-member (ADR 0039)
Grading profile(default)
Verdict mode(default)
Evaluated2026-09-05
Exit code1

Generated by the askit-evaluate collection renderer. Every number here is reproducible: re-run node scripts/evaluate.mjs <catalogue>. This renderer adds no judgment and does not change the verdict.